16 hours ago

IOSCO warns quantum computing poses risks to finance and public blockchains

IOSCO Flags Quantum Computing Risk To Blockchains, Finance

Bitcoin Magazine

The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), a global body of securities regulators, released a 63-page report on Thursday warning about quantum computing. IOSCO described quantum computing as a significant cybersecurity challenge for financial markets over the medium to long term. IOSCO said no practical quantum computer currently exists that can compromise widely used cryptography. IOSCO board chair Jean-Paul Servais said the financial sector should prepare now because the transition will be lengthy and extensive.

The final report used responses from IOSCO members and interviews with industry experts and market participants. IOSCO found that financial-sector preparations remain at an early stage. The report found that most firms are building awareness, establishing governance and cataloguing cryptography, with little migration testing or implementation. Firms identified dependence on third parties, interoperability, shortages of expertise and uncertain timelines as frequent barriers.

IOSCO said public blockchains face greater difficulties because cryptography forms part of the networks' fundamental design. The report said replacing that cryptography requires hard forks and coordination among thousands of independent validators and node operators. IOSCO warned that decentralized networks cannot compel rapid upgrades, potentially making migration slow and fragmented.

The report said ML-DSA-44, a post-quantum standard from the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology, produces signatures of about 2,420 bytes. The report put those signatures at roughly 35 to 40 times the size of today's common 64-byte signatures. IOSCO warned that larger signatures could put pressure on throughput, storage and fees. IOSCO cited tests on Solana's quantum-resistant testnet showing an approximately 90% reduction in throughput.

The report warned that a sufficiently capable attacker could calculate private keys from public keys already visible on a network. IOSCO said uneven migration could leave assets associated with exposed keys vulnerable. The report highlighted dormant or abandoned assets whose holders may be unidentifiable or unable to move the assets. IOSCO used Ethereum, Solana and Tron as blockchain examples, without naming bitcoin.

The timing of the threat remains uncertain. IOSCO said conservative estimates place computers capable of defeating current cryptography between 2030 and 2035. Several industry participants argued that firms should prepare for such computers within the next five years, with artificial intelligence potentially accelerating development. The report also warned about "harvest now, decrypt later" attacks, which involve collecting data now for future decryption.

The report introduced no rules but urged firms to begin adopting post-quantum cryptography. IOSCO also urged firms to develop "crypto-agility," meaning the ability to replace cryptography without extensively redesigning systems. The report advised securities regulators to monitor "quantum washing," in which companies exaggerate the capabilities of quantum products. IOSCO said quantum computing will remain a priority in 2027.

Jameson Lopp estimated in May that outputs exposing public keys contained about 6.93 million BTC, equivalent to 34.6% of bitcoin's supply. Lopp's estimate included early pay-to-public-key coins and reused addresses. Lopp argued in a September essay that the debate concerns minimizing failures to protect property rights, rather than merely deciding whether vulnerable coins should be frozen.

Developers have written proposals to address bitcoin's exposure, but none is active. BIP 360 would introduce an output type resembling Taproot that does not expose a public key. BTQ Technologies has implemented BIP 360 on a separate test network. However, BIP 360 offers no protection for coins with keys that are already exposed. Lopp co-authored BIP 361, a draft proposing the gradual elimination of legacy signatures. However, Lopp has said immediate next steps do not include BIP 361. Lopp warned in the September essay: "Waiting until a quantum attacker is visible will leave us with the worst set of possible choices."

This content is an AI-generated summary/analysis for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.