November 12, 07:00

MSCI to remove Strategy from indexes, risking weaker bitcoin purchase funding

MSCI dumps Strategy, putting its bitcoin-buying model on the line

CoinDesk

MSCI confirmed that Strategy will leave MSCI's widely followed global equity indexes, including the MSCI USA Index, after trading closes on November 30. MSCI based the decision on a new screening rule for non-operating companies adopted on October 15. The rule also resulted in the removal of Tokyo-listed bitcoin treasury company Metaplanet from the MSCI Japan Small Cap Index. Strategy, the largest publicly listed bitcoin holder, currently owns 850,364 BTC valued at $62.6 billion. The index exclusion neither removes Strategy from stock exchanges nor requires Strategy to sell bitcoin.

Funds mandated to replicate an index must sell an excluded stock, creating pressure on the share price. BloFin Research estimates that MSCI-tracking funds must sell about 13 million Strategy shares, roughly 3.1% of shares outstanding and less than one typical day's trading volume. Strategy's response to MSCI's consultation similarly put holdings by funds tracking MSCI's global investable indexes at about 13 million shares, or 3.1% of basic shares outstanding. Those holdings were worth approximately $1.6 billion at Wednesday's prices. However, JPMorgan estimated in November 2025 that exclusion from MSCI indexes could cause about $2.8 billion in outflows. JPMorgan estimated potential outflows of $8.8 billion if other index providers followed, but JPMorgan based those forecasts on MSCI's initial proposal rather than the final rules.

BloFin Research warned that forced selling and lost passive demand could reduce Strategy's mNAV premium, making equity issuance less accretive and potentially slowing bitcoin accumulation. The mNAV measure compares Strategy's market valuation with the value of Strategy's bitcoin holdings. A reading above 1 means investors value the shares above the underlying bitcoin, while a reading below 1 indicates the reverse. Strategy has financed bitcoin purchases through convertible notes, preferred stock and common shares sold through an at-the-market program. Share issuance above 1 times mNAV increases bitcoin per share for existing investors because the shares sell for more than the bitcoin backing those shares. Equity issuance adds little value near 1 times mNAV and becomes dilutive below that level. Strategy's mNAV has declined from a peak of 3.4 times in November 2024 to roughly 1.08 times currently.

Strategy's November 9 filing shows that Strategy raised $283.8 million through sales of 2.05 million common shares during the week ended November 8. Strategy allocated $81.9 million to purchasing 1,036 BTC. Strategy spent $188.3 million on repurchases of STRC preferred stock. Strategy added the remaining $13.6 million to cash. The filing recorded a cash reserve of $4.77 billion as of November 8. Strategy withdrew $21.1 million from the reserve that week for preferred dividends. Strategy reported no bitcoin sales.

Markus Thielen, founder of 10x Research, argued that most of the widely anticipated exclusion was already reflected in Strategy's share price. Thielen expects Strategy shares to continue underperforming because a NAV premium near 1.0 gives the shares less leverage to bitcoin. Thielen expects no spillover into bitcoin itself. Thielen said treasury companies have exerted progressively less market influence since bitcoin peaked a year ago. Thielen said shrinking NAV premiums have led many investors to conclude that treasury companies added no value beyond the bitcoin those companies hold. Thielen expects shares sold by benchmark-tracking funds to attract buyers at slightly lower prices. Thielen said announcements of this kind have historically been reflected in prices well before implementation. Thielen added that many funds already held less Strategy stock than their benchmarks required, potentially reducing the eventual selling pressure.

However, independent bitcoin analyst Derin Olenik warned that confirmed exclusion could generate more than $2.8 billion in selling pressure. Olenik estimated selling pressure above $11 billion if other indexes also excluded Strategy. Olenik argued that exclusion would seriously damage the institutional-adoption narrative on which the bitcoin treasury model increasingly depends.

Thielen argued that bitcoin treasury companies should operate more like asset managers, using yield strategies to demonstrate that the companies can outperform the market. Thielen said that approach requires skills different from financial engineering. Olenik welcomed the exclusion and advocated a transition to what Olenik calls "Treasury 2.0". Olenik advocated bitcoin-native operations that acquire bitcoin for productive uses, build infrastructure, expand network adoption and monetary utility, and deploy, earn and compound satoshis for shareholders through real operations in the emerging agentic era.

This content is an AI-generated summary/analysis for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.