November 06, 15:30

Analysis: Bitcoin ETF buying outpaces Q3 mining, but $430 million exits Thursday

Bitcoin ETFs bought nearly twice what miners produced in Q3 -- but $430 million left on Thursday

CryptoSlate

Farside Investors recorded $430 million in withdrawals from US spot Bitcoin ETFs on Nov. 5, Thursday. A Nov. 2 report from 21Shares put third-quarter ETF purchases at 79,800 BTC, compared with mining production of 41,300 BTC. The figures cover the quarter ending Sept. 30. According to 21Shares, Aug. 17-27 and Sept. 21-25 together accounted for 91% of ETF inflows measured in Bitcoin.

ETF purchases amounted to nearly twice mining output, supporting an argument that Bitcoin is becoming scarcer. However, the concentration of purchases in brief periods provides little assurance about current demand. The unresolved issue for holders evaluating a supply squeeze is whether ETF demand continues outside those periods. Existing investors can make previously acquired coins available, so purchases above mining output do not establish the supply buyers must absorb at a particular price.

The 21Shares report also recorded a third-quarter decline of 248,000 BTC in long-term-holder balances. That larger movement makes existing holdings relevant to the scarcity assessment alongside newly issued Bitcoin. However, the balance change represents a net reduction, not a measured volume of completed market sales. ETF ownership may overlap with classifications based on how long investors have held coins. Subtracting the balance reduction from ETF purchases, or treating the reduction as selling additional to mining output, would suggest unsupported accounting precision.

Glassnode's public page provided a more recent indication of the direction of long-term-holder positions. A capture at 10:39 UTC on Nov. 6 displayed approximately negative 151,885 BTC with the label "24 hours ago." The relative timestamp does not identify a specific trading session. The metric tracks the change in the cohort's supply over a rolling 30-day period.

Coins enter the long-term-holder cohort through aging, while spending removes coins from the cohort. A negative value indicates that spending exceeds maturation, not that the displayed quantity was sold in one day. Glassnode uses each entity's average purchase date, applying gradual weighting around 155 days, and omits supply in exchange wallets. The measure therefore covers a particular group rather than every potential seller. The rolling measurement period differs from Q3, so the figures cannot directly establish whether distribution has become faster or slower.

Recurring ETF inflows combined with slower net distribution by older holders would provide stronger evidence of recovery. Continuing redemptions together with ongoing distribution would weaken that case.

This content is an AI-generated summary/analysis for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.